In this series of posts I'll discuss a random album in my collection I feel like talking about!
Of course, I'm no Dylan connoisseur. I don't really know what the fuck makes a Dylan album so great; like, I don't really know what makes Highway 61 better than, say, Love and Theft. But ask any critic and presumable any fan, and they'll likely say Highway 61 is the better record. And I don't really know why Blonde on Blonde is considered to be better than Rough and Rowdy Ways. What I'm trying to say is the fact that I am a casual listener of Dylan at most, I suppose it means I can go into any of his albums pretty open-minded. Maybe?
Whatever! What I do know is that I hadn't heard this album for a good few years, despite giving it a fair amount of attention back in 2020 (although not on this blog). I still remembered practically every song on here, which is a good sign. And I think one of the reasons I liked this album more-so than many of the others I picked up is the fact I actually think I prefer old Dylan's voice to young Dylan's voice, as mental as that sounds. If we're being honest, I don't think a lot of people consider Bob to be a good singer in terms of vocal ability. This doesn't really bother me - after all, look at all the metal and other shit I listen to, what percentage of those guys can actually sing?! If the vocals suit the music and vibe, then they don't have to be impressive. Neil Young is a prime example of this, so is Billy Corgan. And Lemmy. Ozzy anyone? And the same is true with Bob Dylan! But there's something about the weathered, haggard 79 year old Bob that just works for me when it comes to this album. I couldn't imagine his nasally, higher-pitched style of his earlier days working well with any of these tracks.
The blues songs, 'False Prophet', 'Goodbye Jimmy Reed' and 'Crossing the Rubycon', are great. They sound like the product of a seasoned blues band playing some dive bar in the Deep South. They're "rough", just like the album title suggests, although maybe not particularly "rowdy"! Again, old Bob's vocals really suits the style of these tracks. I also like the folky, if oddly dark 'My Own Version of You', plus the super-smooth ballad 'I've Made Made Up My Mind to Give Myself to You', with it's almost gospel/lullaby-like aura. It stands out in a good way. 'Mother of Muses' is pleasant enough, and strangely, I actually quite enjoy opening track 'I Contain Multitudes'. I say "strangely" because it's essentially a simplistic acoustic folk song with spoken-word vocals from Bob, talking about, erm, a "multitude" of crap I don't really understand (sorry)! But I like it!
Yeah, I'm not much of a lyrics guy when it comes down to it. They're not even a big deal for me when it comes to concept albums. Maybe that's one of the reasons why I'm not really a fan of Bob, even if I admire him. There's moments on this album where I really have no idea what the fuck Dylan is waffling on about, or trying to say. I wasn't sure if Bob was literally talking about himself on 'I Contain Multitudes', but in reality I think he's just talking about people in general. Maybe I'm just a total dumbass, because a lot of critic reviews of this album talk in much more detail about the lyrics, which is probably a fairer way to critique Bob's works in all fairness. For me, I somewhat pay attention, but I like a lot of what this album has to offer either way, so it's not really a big deal whichever way you look at it - from my perspective of course. Don't get me wrong, there are songs with lyrics that do resonate with me. But I certainly don't claim to be a lyrics guy, so unless the wordplay is so utterly terrible and embarrassingly stupid, they don't tend to affect my enjoyment of an artist too much.
That said, it's hard to avoid the lyrics to the album's finale, the near-17 minute 'Murder Most Foul'. It's kind of a heartfelt epic about the assassination of President John F. Kennedy. It's basically an analysis of Americana and the decay of political trust/values in the USA. And there's probably a whole lot more to take away from Bob's storytelling in this one too, I'm just not smart enough to really get much more out of it than that! But I totally appreciate what the man was trying to do with this song, and it's probably the only song on here where I actually like the lyrics more-so than I do the music. It's entirely spoken-word, in similar fashion to 'I Contain Multitudes', with no real instrumentational melody/structure to speak off. There is soft background music of course, but it feels to me like it's there to set the tone for the vocals. The lyrics are the focal point of 'Murder Most Foul' for sure. Once again, I wouldn't want to hear a younger Dylan doing this track. I just don't feel like a younger voice would've had the same impact, especially considering all the themes going on here.
I will say that I don't like everything on here. The slow, lumbering 'Black Rider' bores me. Because the more energetic 'Goodbye Jimmy Reed' comes on straight after, it's completely forgettable to me. Good lyrics at least (ironically after everything I just said in the previous paragraph), but not enough to save me from boredom! The other track I could do without - because I'm a peasant who clearly doesn't fully understand the brilliance of Dylan - is the soft accordion-driven 'Key West (Philosopher Pirate)'. I think I might have appreciated this one more if it wasn't immediately followed up by 'Murder Most Foul'. 'Key West (Philosopher Pirate)' is 9 and a half minutes long, and is then overshadowed by the 16 minute epic. Had it been positioned elsewhere within the tracklisting, maybe I'd have more time for this one, but when played in order as the album was intended, it feels like a bit of a slog to me. This is one of the rare albums I decided to buy as a new release on vinyl instead of CD. I bought a new turntable in 2020, so that was probably why. 'Murder Most Foul' takes up the entirety of side D. If you buy the CD version of the album, 'Murder Most Foul' comes on it's own disc. So maybe 'Key West' is very much Rough and Rowdy Ways' true finale, while 'Murder Most Foul' is actually supposed to be it's own separate thing?
In terms of anything else, I have no qualms with the production. It's a fine-sounding record; all the instruments are as clear as daylight, Bob's vocals are pushed quite high in the mix (but then they should be anyway), and there's absolutely nothing fancy or pretentious about the album in this regard. The lyrics could be considered pretentious to some people I guess, but then I guess Bob Dylan usually wants his listeners to think about what he's saying. And that's why I don't think I'll ever fully understand the man, even if I can still enjoy some of his music here and there!! Like I said, I've always appreciated Bob, and I get why his songs have been covered by SO many other artists throughout history. I want to be Dylan fan, even though I'm not!
And that's my review of Rough and Rowdy Ways. A review from a casual listener at best! I certainly don't hold it to the same degree as a lot of the critics did when it dropped in 2020, and I still don't "get" the album enough to consider it to be great. But I still largely enjoyed hearing it again for the first time in a while, and I suppose it'll always be a go-to Dylan album for me, unless I do somehow become a fully-fledged fan at some point in the future!
Adam's rating: 7.8/10






















